Rebranding... Is It A Good Idea?
Posted on Tue, Aug 24, 2010
I received an email with two terrific questions that I thought would generate some interesting feedback from all of you. So please share your ideas with this store owner by putting a comment on the blog!
I have two burning questions. I have been in business nine years. I bought an existing store whose owner had run it into the ground and claimed bankruptcy five days later. At the time, I wanted to change the name because I hated it (and still do). However, people around me were saying to keep it as it was established. DUH it was going out of business... I shoulda, woulda, coulda.
Fast forward nine years. The store is rocking. It's well branded, is a destination store, etc, etc. I STILL HATE THE NAME! Each time I give it at a trade show or whatever, I am embarrassed of because it does not encompass what we are at all. I have tried adding a jazzy tagline but it still irks the heck out of me. I am wondering about changing the name to coincide with our 10yr anniversary. I have other changes on the way and the building needs a bit of a facelift so we'd do it all at once and do an "unveiling" of sorts.... Have window lettering saying formerly ________.
I can't even imagine the marketing campaign I would have to embark on! However, lame as it may be, most of my customers call the shop Vickie's. I got it at Vickie's ... you need to see Vickie, etc. Now I KNOW you shouldn't call a shop your name but it would certainly be an easy transition…customers wouldn't be that rattled by it... What do you think? Is it EVER a good idea to change your name? How much marketing are we talking here?
Now, if I can be so bold as to ask two questions, my shop started as a consignment shop. Over the nine years, we have become approximately 1/2 new product. There isn't much competition in my town... I'm IT if you want fashionable goods at a reasonable price. My NEW sales have now reached 70% of my total sales. At some point, I would love to switch over to just new as the consignment is labor intensive, etc. That 30% that the consigned is making me is still a good chunk of change though... I have divided into quarters how much more new product I would need to buy to sell that other 30% (working backwards) who knows? Maybe I'd sell more if it was all new? The consigned goods are taking up ALL of my second floor (1200sq feet) and 1/3 of my main floor which is 1600sq feet so dollar for dollar, it's a no brainer... HELP!
I look forward to your reply.
Let’s break this down into separate discussion/learning points. The first lesson to be learned, and I wish I had learned it earlier in my career, is that we must do our due diligence when purchasing a business. That means we have to do credit checks, check with key vendors, do focus groups with customers, and have all of the financials professionally examined with copies of the tax returns. The returns should be for the business, if it is a corporation, and the tax returns of the owners, therefore, avoiding some of the problems.
Changing the name when buying the business certainly seems like it would have been the optimum time. However, do not beat yourself up over that because even the worst of business reputations can still have some value. Let me share a first- hand example of one of my biggest blunders. I bought a 98-year old men’s store that was run down, but to me had so much potential. Many of my customers shopped both my women’s store and this men’s store. Perhaps I was a bit arrogant because of my retail successes and because my store did seven times the volume than this men’s store did (my store did $2.1 million in sales, the men’s store did $300,000). I changed the name of the men’s store because I didn’t see any real value in it. The bottom line was it did not work and as bad as I thought the reputation was, it still had some brand awareness.
As for businesses with terrible names, you are not alone. Can you tell me that Abercrombie & Fitch is a great name? Or how about Aeropostale (I cannot pronounce that name and had to go to a mall directory to find how to spell it), Swarovski, Crabtree & Evelyn, and L’Occltane? And then “but with a name like Smuckers it has to be good!” I never realized that Shakespeare was a retail consultant when he gave the advice “what’s in a name?”
Again, I had to live with a name that I hated for 25 years. The name of my store was Ruth’s. Now when you put an apostrophe and an s after Ruth, you almost need to have a hair lisp to pronounce it properly. Plus it is an old biblical name which hadn’t really been used and has fallen out of favor for a couple of generations. Basically, we only knew old people who would use that name. And coupled with the fact that the store was located in a city that had a blue collar and a rough reputation, it made for a difficult image. People would think that we only sold clothes to tough little old ladies. Then when the miniseries Roots was first broadcast, everybody would spell my name wrong. If all of that wasn’t bad enough, I worked with my mother, Ruth, which made me Baby Ruth. For twenty-five years of my life, I was referred to as a candy bar!
But with all that, I took a store that did $279,000 worth of business with 900 square feet to a store that produced $2.6 million with 10,000 square feet. Yes, I thought of every which way possible to change the name but am glad I never did.
Next point – whoever said that a store should not be named after an individual? Sorry, that is bad advice. There are more stores named after people who are highly successful. I will list a few – Kay Jewelers, Jessica McClintock, Johnston & Murphy, Ann Taylor, Auntie Anne’s, Max Studio, Joseph A. Banks, Victoria’s Secret, and Chico’s. One of the points that I have made for years is that regardless of the name of the business, they will still refer to the store as Vicki’s.
My suggestion to any store owner is to put your name in front of the business’ name. An example would be a store named Timeless Gifts, but you put “Sue Smith’s Timeless Gifts” or just “Sue’s Timeless Gifts”. I believe in your case that would probably be the best way to go. Then slowing eliminate The Timeless Gifts.
The store is going to be called by your name regardless. Go with the flow!
As for your question in relationship to marketing costs, it could be gigantic and you run the risk of losing customers. What will happen is there will be a rumor that will get started that you went out of business. You can spend a lot of money and only hurt your business rather than help it. PLEASE DON’T DO IT... LOOK WHAT YOU HAVE DONE SO FAR.
Let’s discuss the issue of consignment. Consignment can be the best part or the worst part of retailing. Let me explain – if you do a consignment agreement whereby you’re splitting 50/50 with the consignee, the return on your efforts can be limited. The way I have seen consignment stores do the best is when the store owner treats the buying process the exact same way as buying regular merchandise. What I mean by that is you have to look at a piece of merchandise as if you were buying it and say “what could I buy this for so that I could sell it at the highest possible mark-up and the fastest rate of sale?” That means you tell the consignee that you will pay $5 for an item while you might put it out for $14.99. There are some people who just want to get rid of stuff and will take anything. By doing the 50/50 split, you are leaving money on the table and besides it is none of their business what you price it at.
I realize that this is a major departure for many consignment businesses. To my defense, I will tell you that the 50+ businesses who have taken this recommendation have thanked me all the way to the bank. This past year, one of the award winning businesses in Massachusetts at the RAMAE Awards Program was a store that coined the term “reborn” and created a small birth certificate that she placed on the merchandise. Look at this blog article from December 2009 that talks about the store which is named Izzy’s.
Last point is the issue of eliminating consignment. This is a personal one, but trust me, if you are working on margins of 4, 5, or 6 times you have to pay the consignee, your feelings toward consignment change dramatically. A few years ago the thought was “let’s separate them”. But because of the popularity and the acceptance of this type of store brought on by the recession and our lingering economic woes, I would be reluctant to totally eliminate it. Let’s see what the readers have to say.
Please write in and I invite everyone’s comments. Share with us your opinions. I look forward to reading them.
P.S. Why is there a bank named the Fifth Third Bank? It sounds like two losers came together – fifth place and third place but went on to become a major force in banking today. Whatever happened to “we are number one”?