Subscribe by Email

Your email:

Rick Segel, CSP

cta webinar

Welcome to Rick Segel's Blog

Current Articles | RSS Feed RSS Feed

Forrest Gump Was Right – Stupid Is What Stupid Does

 

Forrest GumpI want to share three examples of sheer stupidity.

Is the tail wagging the dog or is the dog wagging the tail?

This week I had an eye opening experience that made me feel so stupid that I am compelled to write about it so that you can learn from my mistakes. If you had five customers come into your store and ask for a specific product, would you go out and buy it? YOU BET YOU WOULD. We would pat ourselves on the back for being attentive and listening to our customers by jumping on a trend as early as possible.

We all love to say that we enjoy listening and reacting to our customers. That’s what we call good customer service. Now let’s update that experience into the social media world by writing an article in your newsletter, blog or Facebook. The article you write is about a new product that you just got in. It might not even be an original article by you. You could just offer a link to an article about the product. Now what if your customers responded to your article or link about this new product and asked if you had the product in stock or where they could buy it? Would you think you might have a hot product? Of course you would. What if a hundred customers wrote to you and told you how great it was and expressed an interest to buy it? How excited would you be? How stupid do you think you would feel if you realized you never responded to even one inquiry? Pretty dumb!

I was interviewing a new marketing company that analyzed the data on my website. They even could tell me how many people read an article and passed it on to friends and colleagues. They asked me how dramatically my business changed since April. I was puzzled and didn’t know what they were referring to. They then informed me that the traffic and buzz surrounding 2 of my articles in the month of April generated an additional 67,000 views of these articles. Shame on me for not knowing that, shame on me for not responding to that interest and shame on me for not offering the type of products my readers were interested in.

Can this happen to you? Yes and it’s happening every day because we are getting feedback from our customers in ways we never had. The customers didn’t call or write and say they wanted it, but they expressed interest by sharing with their friends what I wrote. It happens because we add a link that we don’t totally read and we don’t have the time to read or understand all of the analyses available. The lesson to be learned is to monitor the increase in traffic to your site, blog or any social media component. It could change the direction of your business.

Don Quixote lives.

State and federal governments need money; there is no question about that. Jobs and the unemployment rate are the single biggest domestic issues our country is facing. Small businesses generate more jobs than any other part of the economy. Retailing is one of the biggest components of small business. Having said that, how stupid can the governments, both state and federal, be that online merchants can sell products across state lines without having to charge a sales tax. That gives an online merchant a 5, 6 or 7 percent advantage over the local business. That hurts the local business and it’s an unfair advantage, and the state is losing out on all of that revenue. THIS MUST CHANGE! 

I feel like Don Quixote fighting windmills when I mention this to politicians who say “I would never raise taxes.” Don’t you get it? You’re not raising taxes-- you’re just enforcing the taxes that already exist. There will be more to come on this.

It’s more than money.

Being in the retail business we have an advantage in hiring and staffing our businesses. That advantage is our ability to hire people who like what we sell. People who work in jewelry stores like jewelry. People who work in clothing stores like clothing. People who work in car dealerships like cars. The common denominator is they are there for more than the weekly paycheck.

The son of a friend of mine was looking to change jobs. His approach in changing jobs was not the same as most of us. He didn’t send out resumes or respond to ads. He sent out a few strategic letters on ways those companies could increase their revenues and profits. Three letters went out and they all responded. They all invited him to their company to explore his idea. Two of those companies made him offers that are truly beyond the comprehension of the average person – myself included. Granted this person is brilliant with two pristine degrees from the finest colleges in the world. His approach applies to every employee we have.

If we could only teach, train or create the mindset for our employees that this young man adopted which was people will pay for great ideas. I was working in a downtown and this merchant was bragging about this one employee who said “I have an idea how we could rearrange the store and do more business.” The owner liked the idea and told him to go for it which meant he had to work extra hours after the store was closed. The owner didn’t care because he believed in the idea. The bottom line was that employee needed to earn more money and he did it in a creative way.

So the next time one of your employees says “I need more hours or I need more money” tell them you need more ideas to justify what they are asking. Employment is a partnership and it must be treated that way. It must be a win/win and when we get a buy in from our employees, it becomes magical.

Comments

I am a big supporter of local retail but I cannot agree with you on the sales tax issue. 
 
You said, "That gives an online merchant a 5, 6 or 7 percent advantage over the local business. That hurts the local business and it’s an unfair advantage, and the state is losing out on all of that revenue. THIS MUST CHANGE! " 
 
Taxing online sales to "equalize" the "unfair" advantage is just not the only way to look at this issue. 
 
Taxes based upon buying are not good for any retailer. Taxing sales may be the easiest way to collect taxes but it is not the proper way and it is not fair to the poor. 
 
The preferred tax is based upon usage of services and income (tax the rich is a very popular movement right now). 
 
What rate? Sales taxes are 9.75% in Chicago and sales tax in NH are ZERO. Maine citizens drive to NH routinely to save money. 
 
Do you want to force all states to charge 9.75% taxes to make it "Fair"? 
Posted @ Tuesday, November 22, 2011 4:18 AM by Barry Rickert
If the states want to immediately eliminate the sales tax that we merchants collect, I wouldn't argue back with Barry. Barring that, which we know isn't going to happen, any argument that perpetuates the inequity reveals an indifference to our desperate cries for the unfairness to end. What devastates me intellectually is the obtuse "no more taxes" line, even for freeloaders out of state. Lawmakers get elected and reelected by their own state populace, and their refusal to chase down the free money we so desperately need is so discouraging it destroys faith in their integrity and intelligence. Meanwhile, they'd shut me down in a heartbeat and put me in jail if I stopped collecting. We're reaching a flash point, and people are still arguing so they don't have to pay sales tax, or because it's inconvenient to collect it. It's inconvenient for me, too, darn it, and has been forever. Join the club! 
 
The website below offers a wealth of information, including how to reach local lawmakers across the nation. I suspect it's backed by Walmart or some other such erstwhile arch-enemy, but on this point we concur. Government mandated advantage against the core contributors that keep the states afloat is patently indefensible, mean-spirited and ultimately, stupid. I agree, it has to end. And it will.  
 
I'm SO pleasantly surprised to see this issue be taken up by Rick. We need all the help we can get, and Mr. Segel is articulate and passionate as he champions success for independent retailers. Just as with Small Business Saturday, a transparent marketing device for American Express: Their ends are congruent with mine. A healthier independent business infrastructure means a healthier American Express, and a healthier America. THANK YOU, Rick, for weighing in. You never know what the tipping point is that finally wins the point.  
 
www.StandWithMainStreet.com.
Posted @ Tuesday, November 22, 2011 9:25 AM by Peter Rose
Sales tax is complicated - no doubt; but in the State of Washington if we were to purchase a product across State lines and not pay sales tax on it - we are supposed to report that to the Dept of Revenue and pay the tax! 
 
For the business community it is simply put: If you use it in WA, you pay tax on it to WA. We even have a "special" place to report use tax. 
 
So, regarding WA - it is not that the law doesn't exist; it does. The reality is that to enforce the law on the individual consumer would cost more than it would yield. So WA puts its enforcement efforts onto the business owners - not the consumers. 
 
Three things need to occur to solve the problem: 
1) it has to be easy and simple to implement (and WA is certainly neither); 
2) it has to be enforced fairly (WA has missed the boat there as well); and 
3) the taxes collected have to be used for public necessities (WA has REALLY missed that mark). 
 
Too many politicians spend the money like it's free money and gift the money to their special interest groups. 
 
My opinion is that we should start with #3 - then at least we (the business community) would not have to enforce ANOTHER sales tax increase which is putting us in WA at an even greater disadvantage. 
 
Yesterday, our Governor announced her request to increase our sales tax rate another .5 and yet also is allowing a grant to a special interest group of a One Million Dollars. Robbing Peter to pay Paul and the business owner is in the middle. Until you solve both sides of the problem - it won't be fixed.
Posted @ Tuesday, November 22, 2011 11:52 AM by Val Barschaw
Someone wrote not to charge sales tax out of state. Non sense. Everyone in a state, if they bought in a retail would pay sales tax, if they still buy and get it delievered to their home, doesn't matter where the product came from, they should pay tax because if for no other reason, they would if they had NOT bought it from the internet. 
 
 
 
Most of us, me included, think most politicians are NOT doing a good job. But negative state coffers are coming right NOWE mostly from decreased income taxes collected, lower state wide sales which means less sales tax collected. yes the state can cut costs but raising taxes revenue by collected sales tax on items that would be taxed if PICKED up in your own state should be implemented. 
 
 
 
David
Posted @ Thursday, November 24, 2011 9:15 PM by David Geller
Hi Rick, 
 
Thank you for covering an issue that has on my mind. It seems most of our states are having financial issues, however, there doesn't seem to be any effort being made to enforce the collection of sales tax for out of state sales. This seems to be the easiest, quickest fix until the tax system(s) are re-evaluated and/or changed. As a retailer it will be more work but I am willing to make the effort for the greater good. It's time people look at the bigger picture and not the quick fix. 
 
How can we encourage our lawmakers to implement and enforce the collection of sales tax on sales made out of state?
Posted @ Saturday, November 26, 2011 12:36 PM by Michele Karwoski
to B.R. You say it hurts the poor...the poor I know don't shop on-line, and most travel to their local stores to secure resources and pay the applicable taxes. 
On line merchants & customers who sell/buy goods "elsewhere" are just skirting the additional cost incurred when and if sales tax is added.
Posted @ Tuesday, November 29, 2011 11:13 AM by Teacher's Pet
Responding to Michelle who asks "how can we encourage our lawmakers..." The first answer is to KNOW your lawmakers and make sure they know you. Reach out and introduce yourself and provide them a proposal you think that will help; don't just gripe.  
 
In my State I recently provided a written suggestion to apply property taxes evenly and to remove the "special interest" exemption. Hey, it may not be popular - but it is fair and my lawmakers respect that I've provided an alternative that could fix the budget "shortage". 
 
The lawmakers are bombarded with lots of noise - so you can make a difference, gain their respect, and hopefully improve the business climate by giving them suggestions based on facts (not feelings). It will take extra effort on your part because you will have to know the facts first (as a business owner you should know these).  
 
Plus you will feel better knowing you are trying to make an improvement.
Posted @ Thursday, December 01, 2011 1:09 PM by Val Barschaw
Comments have been closed for this article.